STEREOTYPICAL BELIEFS ABOUT SEXUAL ASSAULT

It appears that Britain is way behind us in the prosecution of sexual assault (or rape) charges. We prohibit the asking of questions in cross-examination of complainants that suggest common false stereotypical beliefs about sexual assault. Some of these myths are:

The “Fight Back” or “Active Resistance” Myth: The belief that a genuine victim will always scream, fight back physically, try to escape, or sustain visible injuries. In reality, a freeze response (tonic immobility), dissociation, or compliance out of fear of greater harm is a very common physiological reaction to trauma.

The “Prompt Complaint” Myth: The assumption that a real victim will report the assault to police or tell someone immediately, and that any delay in reporting means the accusation is fabricated.

The “Clothing, Location, or Alcohol” Myth: The idea that a victim’s attire, intoxication, or decision to go somewhere alone (such as a private room or a bar) invites assault or implies consent.

The “Stranger Danger” Myth: The misconception that sexual assault is almost always committed violently by a stranger in a dark alley, rather than by an acquaintance, partner, colleague, or someone the victim knows and trusts.

The “Prior Sexual History” or “Promiscuity” Myth: The belief that someone who has had many sexual partners, or who previously consented to sex with the accused, is inherently more likely to have consented on the occasion in question or is less credible as a witness (often referred to in Canadian jurisprudence as the “twin myths”).

The “Specific Emotional Demeanor” Myth: The expectation that a traumatized victim will always appear visibly hysterical, tearful, or emotionally broken on the witness stand, rather than calm, detached, or matter-of-fact.

The “Malicious Fabrication” Myth: The belief that false accusations of sexual assault are widespread and frequently made out of regret, spite, or a desire for attention or financial gain.

https://ca.news.yahoo.com/barristers-must-stop-using-rape-133457827.html?guccounter=1

THE PURPOSE OF JAIL IS TO PUNISH, DETER AND SEPARATE FROM SOCIETY WHERE NECESSARY. NOT TO BE INHUMANE.

Getting assigned to a two-person cell only to find two inmates already living there means a brutal pecking order has to be sorted out immediately. Who ends up sleeping on the bare floor between the bunks, with their head dangerously close to the toilet? That kind of hierarchy isn’t negotiated—it’s enforced. And once the dust settles, you’re locked inside that overcrowded cell for hours or even days during endless lockdowns, sharing every suffocatingly claustrophobic inch with the same two cellmates.

https://ca.news.yahoo.com/ontario-government-criticized-removing-minimum-090000519.html

Sexual history has always been capable of being relevant in a sexual offence trial as long as it’s not tendered for the purpose of promoting the twin myths that the complainant is more likely to have consented to the sexual activity or is less worthy of being believed.

“While evidence of a complainant’s prior sex work should not be adduced to show a propensity to engage in sex work or sexual activity generally, such evidence may be relevant for other legitimate inferential purposes, as in the instant case,” (Justice) Moreau said in the decision. Moreau said it’s the job of the courts to “balance the elimination of myths and stereotypes in sexual offence cases with the accused’s right to full answer and defence.”

https://www.pentictonherald.ca/news/national_news/article_bae22083-e69b-5415-8a95-61de0b02637b.html

Do we need more police officers? According to City News, that’s what Torontonians want. What does that mean?

“Around three-quarters of Toronto and GTA residents say they want more officers on the streets while at the same time favouring to keep police budgets steady, a new poll finds. The Canada Pulse Insights poll conducted for CityNews found 73 per cent of Torontonians and 76 per cent of GTA residents surveyed agree there needs to be more police officers on the streets.” Brad Bradford, if elected, wants to hire 1,000 more Toronto police officers.

What do police officers do? They investigate crime and lay charges. One Thousand more officers will lay many new criminal charges. Many of those charges will go to an already failing overworked bail court. It will increase the workload of already overworked Crown Attorneys. It will result in more trials in a court system that can’t manage the present backlog of trials which will result in more of those charges being stayed because of delay. It will result in more overcrowding of an already overcrowded jail system.

Is this really what Toronto wants?

DO HARSH CONDITIONS OF CONFINEMENT INPROVE PUBLIC SAFETY?

Recent policy changes by Premier Doug Ford have removed minimum density requirements in Ontario correctional facilities, compounding existing cell overcrowding. Despite criticism from judges, does intensifying conditions of confinement actually contribute to public safety?

“That observation goes to the heart of the criminal justice debate. Overcrowding does not occur in a vacuum. When you put large numbers of people together in cramped conditions, reduce personal space and heighten the tensions of confinement, conflict becomes more likely. The Star reports that violence among inmates and against correctional officers has increased as Ontario’s jails have become more crowded. If imprisonment leaves people more violent, less stable and less able to support themselves than when they entered, society has not necessarily become safer.

https://www.law360.ca/ca/articles/2535299

Who do we turn to when the police are the corrupt criminals?

“The new details released Wednesday show that the alleged corruption within the city’s police force is even worse than what was described five months ago.

It is not just a single rogue cop, but a coterie of allegedly corrupt officers who appeared to have little fear of being found out, given how openly they discussed the allegedly criminal behaviour with their colleagues.”

https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/seven-takeaways-from-the-stunning-new-project-south-allegations/article_852b3be6-e2f3-40c7-8064-215c237047f8.html?source=newsletter&utm_source=ts_nl&utm_medium=email&utm_email=0B41BB051FF7EA38DB4BDD5E33BA3AB2&utm_campaign=frst-wk_42910

Michael Spratt explains the purpose behind Doug Ford’s intrusion into federal law.

“Ford and Downey have passed a law they know will be struck down, so they can launch a performative attack when it is. And in doing so, they deliberately undermine confidence in courts, plow under the Charter and civil liberties, and use real human suffering to manufacture a political grievance.

Ontario’s cash bail law will be found unconstitutional. And when Ford inevitably expresses outrage that a judge has done exactly what everyone knew a judge would do, remember this: that won’t mean his plan failed. It will mean it worked exactly as intended.”

https://www.canadianlawyermag.com/news/opinion/ontarios-cash-bail-law-is-unconstitutional-and-ford-knows-it/394586